Let's Talk about Eyeliner and Mascara...

naturalbehonest
Jul 4
4 min read

Updated: Jul 30

Let’s be honest—who doesn’t love a bold, beautiful eye look? Eyeliner and mascara are essential to so many of our beauty routines. But with so many ingredients in cosmetics that we can’t even pronounce, it’s hard to know which products are safe for our delicate eye area. If you're looking to make the switch to non-toxic, cleaner beauty, you're in the right place. Let's talk about some of the best non-toxic eyeliners and mascaras that’ll not only enhance your beauty but protect your eyes and skin.

Let’s explore the best non-toxic pencil and liquid eyeliners that’ll give you the stunning eye looks you love—without the worry."

RMS Beauty Swift Eye Pencil
RMS pencil eyeliner coming in at $25. -Click here to check it out on Amazon #commissionearned https://amzn.to/4nUMahw
Why We Love It: This pencil eyeliner is creamy and easy to apply, with rich pigmentation. It’s made with organic ingredients like jojoba oil and shea butter, so it glides on smoothly without irritating your eyes or skin.
Best For: Anyone looking for a gentle, creamy pencil eyeliner that’s perfect for sensitive eyes.
Key Ingredients: Organic jojoba oil, shea butter, natural pigments.
Alima Pure Natural Eye Pencil
Coming in at $26. -Click here to check it out on Amazon #commissionsearned https://amzn.to/3IGQHnM
Why We Love It: A soft and smooth application with an emphasis on clean beauty. Made from natural and organic ingredients, Alima Pure’s eye pencil is free from parabens and synthetic dyes. It’s ideal for creating soft lines or smudging for a smoky effect.
Best For: People looking for an organic pencil eyeliner that’s easy to work with and versatile.
Key Ingredients: Mica, natural plant waxes.

Liquid Eyeliners

Ilia Beauty Clean Line Liquid Liner

Coming in at $28 -Click here at to check it out on Amazon here #commissionsearned https://amzn.to/46jIKi6
Why We Love It: Ilia’s liquid liner is perfect for creating defined, precise lines. Its formula is enriched with aloe vera and vitamin E, so it’s gentle on the eyes while offering long-lasting color. The brush tip ensures easy application without any mess.
Best For: Anyone who wants a precise, long-lasting liquid liner without harsh chemicals.
Key Ingredients: Aloe vera, vitamin E, organic ingredients.
100% Pure Long Last Liquid Eye Liner
Coming in at $30. It is currently not available on Amazon. Here is the link to their website Long Last Liquid Eye Liner – 100% PURE
Why We Love It: This liquid liner uses fruit pigments and natural plant-based ingredients to create a rich, lasting color without synthetic dyes. Its smooth formula is easy to apply and gives you that perfect cat-eye look without irritation.
Best For: Those who want vibrant color with a non-toxic formula that lasts all day.
Key Ingredients: Fruit pigments, plant-based ingredients.
Now Let's Dive into Mascaras
1. Ilia Beauty Limitless Lash Mascara
Coming in at $29 -Click here to check it out on Amazon #commissions earned https://amzn.to/45dg0FF
- Why We Love It: This mascara offers buildable volume and length with a formula that nourishes lashes. It's made with clean, organic ingredients, including plant-based waxes and shea butter, and delivers a smudge-proof, long-lasting finish.
- Best For: Those who want length and volume without compromising on a clean formula.
- Key Ingredients: Organic shea butter, beeswax, olive oil, vitamin E.
2. RMS Beauty Volumizing Mascara
Coming in at $29 -Click here to check it out on Amazon #commissionsearned https://amzn.to/4oeA4Qy
- Why We Love It: RMS Beauty's mascara is formulated with natural ingredients that nourish and protect your lashes while delivering volume and definition. It’s great for sensitive eyes and is free from synthetic chemicals, parabens, and fragrances.
- Best For: Sensitive eyes or those looking for a more natural, nourishing mascara.
- Key Ingredients: Organic jojoba oil, beeswax, natural pigments.
3. 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented® Ultra Lengthening Mascara
Coming in at $27 -Click here to check it out on Amazon #commissionsearned https://amzn.to/45i0rwn
- Why We Love It: This mascara is packed with fruit pigments and offers dramatic length and separation. It’s made from natural ingredients that promote lash health and is great for those looking to avoid synthetic chemicals.
- Best For: Anyone who wants long, defined lashes with a non-toxic formula.
- Key Ingredients: Fruit pigments, vitamin E, green tea, and aloe vera.
4. W3ll People Expressionist Mascara
Coming in at $20 -Click here to check it out on Amazon #commissionsearned https://amzn.to/4l4VM6O
- Why We Love It: This mascara is formulated with natural ingredients that lengthen and separate lashes, offering a flake-free, long-lasting effect. It’s free of parabens and synthetic fragrances, ideal for clean beauty lovers.
- Best For: Anyone who needs a natural look with long-lasting performance.
- Key Ingredients: Aloe vera, sunflower oil, vitamin E.
Make the change to non-toxic eyeliner and mascara, because your beautiful eyes deserve natural ingredients. So, ditch the harsh stuff and let your lashes and liner do their thing, naturally. Your eyes will look amazing, and your skin will thank you. Embrace clean beauty, because you and your eyes deserve it!

Which type of eyeliner or mascara are you using? Have you tried any of these non-toxic options? Share your thoughts in the comments below and let me know which clean beauty products you might try or are using.
Thanks for stopping in.